#lang racket/base (require "test-utils.rkt" (types subtype numeric-tower union utils abbrev) (rep type-rep values-rep) (env init-envs type-env-structs) rackunit (for-syntax racket/base)) (provide tests) (gen-test-main) (define-syntax (subtyping-tests stx) (define (single-test stx) (syntax-case stx (FAIL) [(FAIL t s) (syntax/loc stx (test-check (format "FAIL ~a" '(t s)) (lambda (a b) (not (subtype a b))) t s))] [(t s) (syntax/loc stx (test-check (format "~a" '(t s)) subtype t s))])) (syntax-case stx () [(_ cl ...) (with-syntax ([(new-cl ...) (map single-test (syntax->list #'(cl ...)))]) (syntax/loc stx (begin (test-suite "Tests for subtyping" new-cl ...))))])) (define t1 (-mu T (-lst (Un (-v a) T)))) (define t2 (unfold t1)) (define tests (subtyping-tests ;; trivial examples (Univ Univ) (-Number Univ) (-Boolean Univ) (-Symbol Univ) (-Void Univ) [-Number -Number] [(Un (-pair Univ (-lst Univ)) -Null) (-lst Univ)] [(-lst* -Number -Number (-val 'foo)) (-lst Univ)] [(-lst* -Number -Number (-val 'foo)) (-lst (Un -Number -Symbol))] [(-pair (-val 6) (-val 6)) (-pair -Number -Number)] [(-val 6) (-val 6)] ;; unions [(Un -Number) -Number] [(Un -Number -Number) -Number] [(Un -Number -Symbol) (Un -Symbol -Number)] [(Un (-val 6) (-val 7)) -Number] [(Un (-val #f) (Un (-val 6) (-val 7))) (Un -Number (Un -Boolean -Symbol))] [(Un (-val #f) (Un (-val 6) (-val 7))) (-mu x (Un -Number (Un -Boolean -Symbol)))] [(Un -Number (-val #f) (-mu x (Un -Number -Symbol (make-Listof x)))) (-mu x (Un -Number -Symbol -Boolean (make-Listof x)))] ;; intersections [(-unsafe-intersect -Number) -Number] [(-unsafe-intersect -Number -Symbol) -Number] [(-unsafe-intersect -Boolean -Number) -Number] [(-unsafe-intersect -Number -Number) -Number] [FAIL -Number (-unsafe-intersect -Boolean -Number)] [(-unsafe-intersect -Boolean -Number) (-unsafe-intersect -Boolean -Number)] [(-unsafe-intersect -Sexp (Un -Null (-pair -Sexp (-unsafe-intersect (make-Listof Univ) -Sexp)))) (make-Listof Univ)] [(-unsafe-intersect (-v A) (-v B)) (Un -String (-unsafe-intersect (-v A) (-v B)))] ;; sexps vs list*s of nums [(-mu x (Un -Number -Symbol (make-Listof x))) (-mu x (Un -Number -Symbol -Boolean (make-Listof x)))] [(-mu x (Un -Number (make-Listof x))) (-mu x (Un -Number -Symbol (make-Listof x)))] [(-mu x (Un -Number (make-Listof x))) (-mu y (Un -Number -Symbol (make-Listof y)))] ;; a hard one [(-mu x (Un -Number (-lst* x -Symbol x))) -Sexp] [t1 (unfold t1)] [(unfold t1) t1] ;; simple function types ((Univ . -> . -Number) (-Number . -> . Univ)) [(Univ Univ Univ . -> . -Number) (Univ Univ -Number . -> . -Number)] ;; simple list types [(make-Listof -Number) (make-Listof Univ)] [(make-Listof -Number) (make-Listof -Number)] [FAIL (make-Listof -Number) (make-Listof -Symbol)] [(-mu x (make-Listof x)) (-mu x* (make-Listof x*))] [(-pair -Number -Number) (-pair Univ -Number)] [(-pair -Number -Number) (-pair -Number -Number)] ;; from page 7 [(-mu t (-> t t)) (-mu s (-> s s))] [(-mu s (-> -Number s)) (-mu t (-> -Number (-> -Number t)))] ;; polymorphic types [(-poly (t) (-> t t)) (-poly (s) (-> s s))] [FAIL (make-Listof -Number) (-poly (t) (make-Listof t))] [(-poly (a) (make-Listof (-v a))) (make-Listof -Number)] ;; [(-poly (a) -Number) -Number] [(-val 6) -Number] [(-val 'hello) -Symbol] [(-set -Number) (make-Sequence (list -Number))] [-FlVector (make-Sequence (list -Flonum))] [-FlVector (make-Sequence (list -Number))] [-FxVector (make-Sequence (list -Fixnum))] [-FxVector (make-Sequence (list -Number))] [((Un -Symbol -Number) . -> . -Number) (-> -Number -Number)] [(-poly (t) (-> -Number t)) (-mu t (-> -Number t))] ;; not subtypes [FAIL (-val 'hello) -Number] [FAIL (-val #f) -Symbol] [FAIL (Univ Univ -Number -Number . -> . -Number) (Univ Univ Univ . -> . -Number)] [FAIL (-Number . -> . -Number) (-> Univ Univ)] [FAIL (Un -Number -Symbol) -Number] [FAIL -Number (Un (-val 6) (-val 11))] [FAIL -Symbol (-val 'Sym)] [FAIL (Un -Symbol -Number) (-poly (a) -Number)] ;; bugs found [(Un (-val 'foo) (-val 6)) (Un (-val 'foo) (-val 6))] [(-poly (a) (make-Listof (-v a))) (make-Listof (-mu x (Un (make-Listof x) -Number)))] [FAIL (make-Listof (-mu x (Un (make-Listof x) -Number))) (-poly (a) (make-Listof a))] [(-val -34.2f0) -NegSingleFlonum] ;; case-lambda [(cl-> [(-Number) -Number] [(-Boolean) -Boolean]) (-Number . -> . -Number)] ;; special case for unused variables [-Number (-poly (a) -Number)] [FAIL (cl-> [(-Number) -Boolean] [(-Boolean) -Number]) (-Number . -> . -Number)] ;; varargs [(->* (list -Number) Univ -Boolean) (->* (list -Number) -Number -Boolean)] [(->* (list Univ) -Number -Boolean) (->* (list -Number) -Number -Boolean)] [(->* (list -Number) -Number -Boolean) (->* (list -Number) -Number -Boolean)] [(->* (list -Number) -Number -Boolean) (->* (list -Number) -Number Univ)] [(->* (list -Number) -Number -Number) (->* (list -Number -Number) -Number)] [(->* (list -Number) -Number -Number) (->* (list -Number -Number -Number) -Number)] [(->* (list -Number -Number) -Boolean -Number) (->* (list -Number -Number) -Number)] [FAIL (->* (list -Number) -Number -Boolean) (->* (list -Number -Number -Number) -Number)] [(->* (list -Number -Number) -Boolean -Number) (->* (list -Number -Number -Boolean -Boolean) -Number)] [(-poly (a) (cl-> [() a] [(-Number) a])) (cl-> [() (-pair -Number (-v b))] [(-Number) (-pair -Number (-v b))])] ;[(-values (list -Number)) (-values (list Univ))] [(-poly (b) ((Un (make-Base 'foo #'dummy values #f) (-struct #'bar #f (list (make-fld -Number #'values #f) (make-fld b #'values #f)))) . -> . (-lst b))) ((Un (make-Base 'foo #'dummy values #f) (-struct #'bar #f (list (make-fld -Number #'values #f) (make-fld (-pair -Number (-v a)) #'values #f)))) . -> . (-lst (-pair -Number (-v a))))] [(-poly (b) ((-struct #'bar #f (list (make-fld -Number #'values #f) (make-fld b #'values #f))) . -> . (-lst b))) ((-struct #'bar #f (list (make-fld -Number #'values #f) (make-fld (-pair -Number (-v a)) #'values #f))) . -> . (-lst (-pair -Number (-v a))))] [(-poly (a) (a . -> . (make-Listof a))) ((-v b) . -> . (make-Listof (-v b)))] [(-poly (a) (a . -> . (make-Listof a))) ((-pair -Number (-v b)) . -> . (make-Listof (-pair -Number (-v b))))] [FAIL (-poly (a b) (-> a a)) (-poly (a b) (-> a b))] [FAIL (-poly (a) (-poly (b) (-pair a b))) (-poly (a) (-poly (b) (-pair b a)))] ;; The following currently are not subtypes, because they are not replacable ;; in an instantiation context. It may be sound for them to be subtypes but ;; the implications of that change are unknown. [FAIL (-poly (x) (-lst x)) (-poly (x y) (-lst x))] [FAIL (-poly (y z) (-lst y)) (-poly (z y) (-lst y))] [FAIL (-poly (y) (-poly (z) (-pair y z))) (-poly (y z) (-pair y z))] [FAIL (-poly (y z) (-pair y z)) (-poly (y) (-poly (z) (-pair y z)))] ;; polymorphic function types should be subtypes of the function top [(-poly (a) (a . -> . a)) top-func] (FAIL (-> Univ) (null Univ . ->* . Univ)) [(cl->* (-Number . -> . -String) (-Boolean . -> . -String)) ((Un -Boolean -Number) . -> . -String)] [(-struct #'a #f null) (-struct #'a #f null)] [(-struct #'a #f (list (make-fld -String #'values #f))) (-struct #'a #f (list (make-fld -String #'values #f)))] [(-struct #'a #f (list (make-fld -String #'values #f))) (-struct #'a #f (list (make-fld Univ #'values #f)))] [(-val 0.0f0) -SingleFlonum] [(-val -0.0f0) -SingleFlonum] [(-val 1.0f0) -SingleFlonum] [(-pair -String (-lst -String)) (-seq -String)] [FAIL (-pair -String (-lst -Symbol)) (-seq -String)] [FAIL (-pair -String (-vec -String)) (-seq -String)] [(-mpair -String -Null) (-seq -String)] [(-mlst -String) (-seq -String)] [(-mpair -String (-mlst -String)) (-seq -String)] [FAIL (-mpair -String (-mlst -Symbol)) (-seq -String)] [FAIL (-mpair -String (-vec -String)) (-seq -String)] [(-mpair -String (-mlst (-val "hello"))) (-seq -String)] [(-Param -Byte -Byte) (-Param (-val 0) -Int)] [FAIL (-Param -Byte -Byte) (-Param -Int -Int)] [(-Param -String -Symbol) (cl->* (-> -Symbol) (-> -String -Void))] [(-vec t1) (-vec t2)] [(make-HeterogeneousVector (list t1)) (-vec t2)] [(make-HeterogeneousVector (list t1 t2)) (make-HeterogeneousVector (list t2 t1))] [(-box t1) (-box t2)] [(-thread-cell t1) (-thread-cell t2)] [(-channel t1) (-channel t2)] [(-mpair t1 t2) (-mpair t2 t1)] [(-HT t1 t2) (-HT t2 t1)] [(make-Prompt-Tagof t1 t2) (make-Prompt-Tagof t2 t1)] [(make-Continuation-Mark-Keyof t1) (make-Continuation-Mark-Keyof t2)] ;; evts [(-evt t1) (-evt t2)] [FAIL (-evt -Byte) (-evt -String)] [-Semaphore (-evt -Semaphore)] [FAIL -Semaphore (-evt -Int)] [-Output-Port (-evt -Output-Port)] [FAIL -Output-Port (-evt -Int)] [-Input-Port (-evt -Input-Port)] [FAIL -Input-Port (-evt -Int)] [-TCP-Listener (-evt -TCP-Listener)] [FAIL -TCP-Listener (-evt -Int)] [-Thread (-evt -Thread)] [FAIL -Thread (-evt -Int)] [-Subprocess (-evt -Subprocess)] [FAIL -Subprocess (-evt -Int)] [-Will-Executor (-evt -Will-Executor)] [FAIL -Will-Executor (-evt -Int)] [(make-CustodianBox -String) (-evt (make-CustodianBox -String))] [FAIL (make-CustodianBox -String) (-evt -String)] [(-channel -String) (-evt -String)] [FAIL (-channel -String) (-evt -Int)] [-Log-Receiver (-evt (make-HeterogeneousVector (list -Symbol -String Univ (Un (-val #f) -Symbol))))] [FAIL -Log-Receiver (-evt -Int)] [(-val 5) (-seq -Nat)] [(-val 5) (-seq -Byte)] [-Index (-seq -Index)] [-NonNegFixnum (-seq -NonNegFixnum)] [-Index (-seq -Nat)] [FAIL (-val -5) (-seq -Nat)] [FAIL -Fixnum (-seq -Fixnum)] [FAIL -NonNegFixnum (-seq -Index)] [FAIL (-val 5.0) (-seq -Nat)] [(-polydots (a) (->... (list Univ) (a a) (make-ValuesDots null a 'a))) (-polydots (a) (->... (list -String) (a a) (make-ValuesDots null a 'a)))] [(-polydots (a) (->... null (Univ a) (make-ValuesDots (list (-result a)) a 'a))) (-polydots (a) (->... null (-String a) (make-ValuesDots (list (-result a)) a 'a)))] [(-polydots (a) (->... null (a a) (make-ValuesDots (list (-result -String)) -String 'a))) (-polydots (a) (->... null (a a) (make-ValuesDots (list (-result Univ)) Univ 'a)))] [(-polydots (a) (->... null (Univ a) (-values (list Univ)))) (->* null Univ Univ)] [(-polydots (a) (->... null (a a) (make-ListDots a 'a))) (-> -String -Symbol (-Tuple (list -String -Symbol)))] [(-> -String -Symbol (-Tuple (list -String -Symbol))) (-polydots (a) (-> -String -Symbol (-lst (Un -String -Symbol))))] [(-polydots (a) (->... null (a a) (make-ListDots a 'a))) (-poly (a b) (-> a b (-Tuple (list a b))))] [(-polydots (b a) (-> (->... (list b) (a a) (make-ValuesDots (list (-result b)) a 'a)) Univ)) (-polydots (a) (-> (->... (list) (a a) (make-ValuesDots null a 'a)) Univ))] [(-polydots (a) (->... (list) (a a) (make-ListDots a 'a))) (-polydots (b a) (->... (list b) (a a) (-pair b (make-ListDots a 'a))))] [FAIL (-polydots (c a b) (->... (list (->... (list a) (b b) c) (-vec a)) ((-vec b) b) (-vec c))) (->* (list (->* (list) -Symbol -Symbol)) (-vec -Symbol) (-vec -Symbol))] [(-> Univ -Boolean : (-PS (-is-type 0 -Symbol) (-not-type 0 -Symbol))) (-> Univ -Boolean : -tt-propset)] [(-> Univ -Boolean : -ff-propset) (-> Univ -Boolean : (-PS (-is-type 0 -Symbol) (-not-type 0 -Symbol)))] [(-> Univ -Boolean : (-PS (-is-type 0 -Symbol) (-not-type 0 -Symbol))) (-> (Un -Symbol -String) -Boolean : (-PS (-is-type 0 -Symbol) (-not-type 0 -Symbol)))] [FAIL (-> Univ -Boolean : (-PS (-is-type 0 -Symbol) (-not-type 0 -Symbol))) (-> Univ -Boolean : (-PS (-is-type 0 -String) (-not-type 0 -String)))] ;; subtyping for types inside propositions [(-> Univ -Boolean : (-PS (-is-type 0 -Symbol) (-not-type 0 -Symbol))) (-> Univ -Boolean : (-PS (-is-type 0 (-opt -Symbol)) (-not-type 0 -Symbol)))] [(-> Univ -Boolean : (-PS (-is-type 0 -Symbol) (-not-type 0 (-opt -Symbol)))) (-> Univ -Boolean : (-PS (-is-type 0 -Symbol) (-not-type 0 -Symbol)))] [FAIL (-> Univ -Boolean : (-PS (-is-type 0 (-opt -Symbol)) (-not-type 0 (-opt -Symbol)))) (-> Univ -Boolean : (-PS (-is-type 0 -Symbol) (-not-type 0 -Symbol)))] [FAIL (make-ListDots (-box (make-F 'a)) 'a) (-lst (-box Univ))] [(make-ListDots (-> -Symbol (make-F 'a)) 'a) (-lst (-> -Symbol Univ))] ;[FAIL (make-ValuesDots (list) -Symbol 'a) (make-ValuesDots (list (-result -String)) -String 'a)] ;[(-values (list -Bottom)) (-values (list -String -Symbol))] [(-> Univ -Bottom) (-> Univ (-values (list -String -Symbol)))] [(-> Univ -Bottom) (-> Univ (-values-dots null -String 'x))] [FAIL (make-pred-ty -String) (-> Univ (-AnyValues (-is-type 0 -String)))] ;; keyword function types [(->key #:x -Symbol #f Univ) (->key Univ)] [FAIL (->key #:x -Symbol #t Univ) (->key Univ)] [FAIL (->key Univ) (->key #:x -Symbol #t Univ)] [(->key #:x -Symbol #f #:y -Symbol #f Univ) (->key Univ)] [FAIL (->key #:x -Symbol #f #:y -Symbol #t Univ) (->key Univ)] [(->key #:x -Symbol #f #:y -Symbol #f Univ) (->key #:x -Symbol #f Univ)] [(->key #:x -Symbol #f #:y -Symbol #f Univ) (->key #:x -Symbol #t Univ)] [FAIL (->key #:x -Symbol #f Univ) (->key #:x -Symbol #f #:y -Symbol #f Univ)] [(->key #:x -Symbol #f #:y -Symbol #f Univ) (->key #:x -Symbol #t #:y -Symbol #t Univ)] [FAIL (->key #:x -Symbol #t #:y -Symbol #f Univ) (->key #:x -Symbol #f #:y -Symbol #t Univ)] [(->key #:x (-opt -String) #f #:y -Symbol #f Univ) (->key #:x -String #t Univ)] [FAIL (->key #:x -String #f #:y -Symbol #f Univ) (->key #:x (-opt -String) #t Univ)] [(->key -String #:x -Symbol #f #:y -Symbol #f Univ) (->key -String #:x -Symbol #t Univ)] [FAIL (->key -String #:x -Symbol #f #:y -Symbol #f Univ) (->key -Void #:x -Symbol #t Univ)] [(->optkey -String [-String] #:x -Symbol #f #:y -Symbol #f Univ) (->key -String #:x -Symbol #t Univ)] [(->optkey -String [-String] #:x -Symbol #f #:y -Symbol #f Univ) (->optkey -String [-String] #:x -Symbol #t Univ)] [FAIL (->optkey -String [-String] #:x -Symbol #f #:y -Symbol #f Univ) (->optkey -String [-Void] #:x -Symbol #t Univ)] [FAIL (->key -String #:x -Symbol #f #:y -Symbol #f Univ) (->optkey -String [-Void] #:x -Symbol #t Univ)] ;; classes and objects [(-class #:method ((m (-> -Nat))) #:augment ((m (-> -Nat)))) (-class #:method ((m (-> -Nat))) #:augment ((m (-> -Nat))))] [(-object #:method ((m (-> -Nat))) #:augment ((m (-> -Nat)))) (-object #:method ((m (-> -Nat))) #:augment ((m (-> -Nat))))] [(-object #:method ((m (-> -Nat)) (n (-> -Nat)))) (-object #:method ((m (-> -Nat))))] [(-object #:method ((f (-> -Nat))) #:augment ((m (-> -Nat)) (n (-> -Nat)))) (-object #:augment ((m (-> -Nat))))] [(-object #:field ((a -Nat)) #:method ((m (-> -Nat)) (n (-> -Nat)))) (-object #:method ((m (-> -Nat))))] [(-object #:field ((x -Symbol))) (-object #:field ((x -Symbol)))] [(-object #:field ((x -Symbol))) (-object #:field ((x (Un -Symbol (-val #f)))))] [FAIL (-object #:field ((a -Symbol))) (-object #:field ((x -Symbol)))] [FAIL (-object #:field ((a -Symbol))) (-object #:field ((x -String)))] [FAIL (-object #:field ((x -Symbol))) (-object #:field ((x -String)))] [FAIL (-object #:method ((m (-> -String)) (n (-> -String)))) (-object #:method ((x (-> -String))))] [(-object #:method ((m (-> -String)) (n (-> -String)))) (-object #:method ((m (-> -String))))] [FAIL (-object #:method ()) (-object #:method ((m (-> -String))))] [FAIL (-object #:method ((m (-> -Nat)) (n (-> -Nat)))) (-object #:method ((l (-> -Nat)) (m (-> -Nat))))] [(-object #:method ((m (-> -Nat)) (n (-> -Nat)))) (-object #:method ((n (-> -Nat)) (m (-> -Nat))))] [FAIL (-class #:method ((m (-> -Nat)))) (-class #:method ((m (-> -Nat))) #:augment ((m (-> -Nat))))] [FAIL (-class #:method ((m (-> -Nat))) #:augment ((m (-> -Nat)))) (-class #:method ((m (-> -Nat))))] ;; prefab structs [(-prefab 'foo -String) (-prefab 'foo -String)] [(-prefab 'foo -String) (-prefab 'foo (-opt -String))] [(-prefab '(bar foo 1) -String -Symbol) (-prefab 'foo -String)] [(-prefab '(bar foo 1) -String -Symbol) (-prefab 'foo (-opt -String))] [FAIL (-prefab '(foo #(0)) -String) (-prefab '(foo #(0)) (-opt -String))] [(-prefab '(foo 1 #(0)) -String -Symbol) (-prefab '(foo #(0)) -String)] [(-prefab '(bar foo 1 #(0)) -String -Symbol) (-prefab '(foo #(0)) -String)] [FAIL (-prefab '(foo #()) -String) (-prefab '(foo #(0)) (-opt -String))] ;; Proposition subtyping ((make-pred-ty (list -Real) -Boolean (Un (-val 0.0) (-val 0))) (make-pred-ty (list -Int) -Boolean (-val 0))) ))